main index

Matthew 11:28

King James Bible : "Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest."

The message of The Seafarer

of the

forged in Sweden

Words, Words, Swords

It is my loss that I do not have 500 at the moment to lay out on acquiring the the full run of Bruce Mitchell's Old English Syntax, 1985, as quoted by Anne Klinck in The Old English Elegies, so, for the time being, I'm restricted to scanning A Guide to Old English, Mitchell and Robinson, which appeared at more or less the same time. Below is a sample from page 264 of M & R's comments on the central crux of The Seafarer, line circa 58. It must have been their mastery of syntax which led their readers to assume their equivalent mastery of lexis, or what one might call vocabulary. Their interpretation of the central crux, in my view, is irretrievably wrong. There must be something inherently seductive about this imaginative fantasy. In passing, one is tempted to ask, what exactly is the seafarer's "goal" ? The mind is not like a bird, and does not leave the speaker's body in order to return to it and urge him to go anywhere. Instead, the anfloga arrives to gather its prey.

A Guide to Old English, 1988, by Mitchell & Robinson
sceatas means "lap"

Anne Klinck below quotes Mitchell, Syntax: "categorically 'magan + infinitive does not express a wish in OE'". Neither Ezra Pound, nor Burton Raffel, can be regarded as adept in the translation of Anglish into Modern English. Nevertheless Pound felt obliged to start his "refraction" of The Seafarer with "May I "; and Raffel is mentioned by Klinck as suggesting, in Deor, "an optative force in mg". The exact equivalent of mg exists in German mge, Swedish m, and Modern English may. Rendering the opening words of The Seafarer as "I can" is simply wrong.

The Old English Elegies, 2001.
Can May Let

The Sutton Hoo sword, replicated at right and left, was almost certainly forged in Sweden. A shorter version of this weapon would have been called a seax. This would have been the arm of the Angles manning and maintaining what was called by the Romans the Saxon Shore. Neither the Romans, nor the pre-existing Ancient Britons, or Scots, would have been unduly concerned where these men actually came from, and would have indiscriminately called them Saxons, or Sassenachs, or variants thereof, as they were armed with a seax. In time, these settlers would have mingled with the natives, to create what is now known as the British, or English. Those called Saxons simply because of their weapons, however, would have called themselves Angles. They mainly came from what is now Sweden, where there are over 150 place-names starting Angel-, Engel-, or Ingel-. Moreover, "There are over 1,000 place-names beginning with Ing- in Sweden ". See Burns, A Short Comparison, page 308. The god Ingwe was especially associated with Sweden and seen as the progenitor of the Ingling or Yngling lineage, a dynasty of legendary Swedish kings. A strophe of the Anglo-Saxon Rune Poem records that "Ing was first among the East Danes seen by men". The East Danes occupied what is now known as the province of Skne, in Sweden. There are virtually no place-names in what is now Saxony repeated in modern Britain. Saxony was not established as a province until circa 550 AD.

David Burns 1      David Burns 2
Place-names in Sweden

commentaries: one, two, three [more than 60 other versions], four, five, six
annotation       essays & papers       main general index
site text      seafarer birds
archiopterix:     misunderstood words
life & death      personality
Smithers One    Smithers Two
Anfloga BC1          Anfloga BC2
Anglian Land & Language
Seafarer Fidelity
Try This Page

"It is dangerous to be right when authority is wrong". Voltaire

I have been given the impression that I was considered insulting
for having wished to discuss the meaning of The Seafarer.
Does this debate, like others, become increasingly bitter because its issue is so trivial ?

"Ignoring pertinent information makes one an idiot". Ethan Indigo Smith, 2014,
The Complete Patriot's Guide, p 41.
"Condemnation without investigation is the height of ignorance". Albert Einstein
The Complete Patriot's Guide, p 219.

Truth treads on toes.
In 1992 the Vatican conceded that Galileo had been right in 1633.
I wonder if anyone reads this flummery ? They might give me a billet.

of the

forged in Sweden

© Charles Harrison-Wallace 2018
All Rights Reserved

Wahllos schlgt das Schicksal zu
Heute er und morgen du!
Ich hr' von fern die Krhen schrei'n
Im Morgenrot, warum muss das sein?

"no one to keen him but the black hags that do be flying on the sea"