Above: 44¼ x 73; signed W.V.Velde J. Reproduced in Country Life, 25 Jan 1973. See Robinson Vol II, p.1042


Above: 51 x 42; unsigned. Reproduced in Robinson Vol II, p.1041

ANOTHER MONAMY
PROBLEM

"Signatures don't mean much" --- M.S.Robinson, circa 1983

"An English Yacht Head-Reaching"


47½ x 41½ ; "strengthened signature" P. Monamy Pinxt. Auctioned 7 April 2004.

The above painting is causing considerable head-scratching. Its "distinctive details" are described by Michael Robinson in the second volume of his catalogue, page 1042, number [4]. It was known to him from the black and white photograph, below, taken at the time of its exhibition in the Leonard Koetser Gallery, London, Autumn 1969. In April 2004 it appeared at an auction held by Woolley & Wallis, in Salisbury.

In spite of the Monamy signature it bears, it is reasonably clear from Robinson's note that he did not believe it to have been painted by Monamy. Nor do I.


47½ x 41½ ; same as previous picture. Koetser Gallery 1969.


left: 51 x 52; unsigned         right: 47½ x 41½ ; bears Monamy signature


left: 60 x 50; signed W.V.Velde J. on back         right: 47½ x 41½ ; bears Monamy signature


detail from painting bearing Monamy signature: as below: see also signatures here

The signature looks convincing, but the painting of the rigging does not resemble the handiwork of Monamy, as evidenced in other works indubitably by his hand. There are numerous conjectural explanations for this apparent anomaly, which will have to be gone into at a later date.


Cornelius van de Velde monogram, dated 1703, on back of canvas. 25 x 37.


Bonhams. 18 Jan 2011. Unsigned: "Circle of Peter Monamy". 15 x 21½


Unsigned; attributed to Monamy; 23½ x 35½. Sotheby 12/3/86; Lot 4
Described as: "The Royal Sovereign, a smacking yacht with other shipping at sea, 1702-1707"


one of Skelt's views

MONAMY WEBSITE PROBLEM PAGES

painting chronology pages
monamy oddities         monamy anomalies
an english yacht head-reaching
sara van de velde ?         the van de velde studio
hope & glory: what, when, why?
royal william?  or  royal anne?
portchester?        sheerness?
doggett's winner date ?
leemans not monamy
mcdonald monamy & super-pseuds
who painted these pictures?
       
timeline 1652-1698
timeline 1697-1750
monamy website index
       

© Charles Harrison Wallace 2004, 2012, 2015
all rights reserved