Seafarer Essays & Papers

A translation is faithful when it conveys the meaning, not merely the words, of its original.
The aim of the translation on this site is to achieve the closest fidelity to its source, in both manner and meaning.
This text is subject to continuous experiment and improvement.

a summing up

MORE
on Angles Saxons Jutes


The snippet at left was published either in 1999 or 2004. I canot determine exctly which, but I thought it might serve to kick off this page of remarks on yet more and again about the colonists of Ancient Britain. The article is of interest since it more or less represents the general impression current in England among those who might, with a little effort, be better informed.

For a start, the "Anglo-Saxons" did not come from Germany, mainly or at all. Isaac Taylor pointed out as long ago as 1864 that there are hardly any place-names from what is now Saxony represented in England.

Jutes. There is no point in thinking there is anything special about Jutes. Jutes are, simply, Goths; and Goths are Geats and Gauts. In Sweden they are Götar, from Götaland, south of the Swedes, north of Europe.

I don't know about Norway and Denmark, but there are hundreds and hundreds of Swedish place-names repeated in England. David Burns' Short Comparison is 600 pages long. One point about these place-names is that they are obviously mostly pre-Viking.

See Isaac Taylor, below. Excised from that excerpt is Isaac's supposition that Angel, or Angle, derived from "angle" --- a hook, althought that dotty speculation is constantly repeated. The numerous Swedish place-names beginning Angel-, Engel- and Ingel- must derive from Ing. But perhaps you can think of a better explanation. "There are over 1,000 place-names beginning with Ing- in Sweden". Burns, page 308.

Rainbird Clarke, author of East Anglia, 1960, produced a work which is predominantly archaeological, ranging over millenia. However, he has a chapter concentrating on the "Early Saxon age", which he dates very approximately from 400 to 600 AD. In spite of writing 82 years after Isaac Taylor, Rainbird sadly fails to understand that that during this period there was no particular tribe known as "Saxon". All his "Saxons" were actually Angles, from Angleland, ie what is now Sweden; and they spoke Anglish. Anglish was not "Old" English, and modern Swedes may be Gothic but not essentially Germanic. The fact is, imho, the Goths originated in Sweden.


The Geats of Beowulf, Wisconsin, 1967, Jane Acomb Leake
The Well Spring of the Goths, iUniverse, Inc, 2004, Ingemar Nordgren

Serious students seeking to establish the history and influence of the Goths may come across the above two publications. Unfortunately, Leake links the Geats with the Getae, which has not found acceptance elsewhere; and Nordgren's mastery of the English language matches the accuracy of his orthography, valiant though both may be. Nevertheless, insofar as it may be ascertained, I tend to agree with him that the Götar of Sweden fathered not only the Angles of England, the Saxons, the Friesians and the Germans, but also the Vandals, the Visigoths and the Ostrogoths, attracting numerous other peoples as they cut their way towards Rome, Spain and North Africa.

Gaut         Getae        Goth



Low-German ?? Stone knife or celt ??




Errors are made.

"It is dangerous to be right when established authority is wrong." Voltaire.
Henry Sweet is the Aristotle of Anglo-Saxon studies.
The Horace Walpole of Linguistics.
Errors in Understanding.


The following comments are undeniable:

"Accuracy is measured by the degree to which users of a translation get the same meaning which the original text had."
Wayne Leman
"Much of the literature of translation is not about errors in translation; it is about errors in understanding the original ."
E.Bruce Brooks

Click for fidelity, integrity and truth.

© Charles Harrison-Wallace 2018

all rights reserved

 

An edition was published June 2005, limited to 125 copies: ISBN 0-9550 126-0-0

The published text has since been repeatedly revised

anglo-saxon text         manuscript
annotation         essays & papers
swedish angle-names
other versions         main index
mail here
a summing up
skyfarer


From East Anglia, 1960, by Rainbird Clarke: Anglish Place-Names